American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) Covered Calls

American Financial Group, Inc. is an insurance holding company focused on specialty commercial products for businesses. Operating through the Great American Insurance Group, it provides specialized property and casualty coverages. The company emphasizes niche market leadership, disciplined underwriting, and opportunistic investment strategies. AFG is noted for its decentralized management model and a consistent history of returning excess capital through dividends.

You can sell covered calls on American Financial Group, Inc. to lower risk and earn monthly income. Born To Sell's covered call screener gives you customized search capabilities across all possible covered calls but here are a couple of examples for AFG (prices last updated Mon 4:16 PM ET):

Want to make money with covered calls?  Sign Up For A Free Trial

American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) is a Cincinnati-based holding company that traces its roots back to 1872. Today, it operates primarily through the Great American Insurance Group, focusing on specialized commercial insurance for small and mid-sized businesses. As of early 2026, AFG maintains a premier position in the specialty P&C market, characterized by a decentralized operating structure that empowers its 35+ individual business units to make localized underwriting and pricing decisions while benefiting from the parent company’s capital strength.

Core Business and Products

The company’s operations are organized into three primary sub-segments within its Specialty P&C Group: Property and Transportation, Specialty Casualty, and Specialty Financial. Its product suite includes highly specialized lines such as inland marine, ocean marine, agricultural-related coverages (including crop insurance), executive liability, fidelity and surety bonds, and equine mortality. In 2025, AFG reported record core operating profits exceeding $1.1 billion, driven by its ability to avoid commoditized "general" insurance markets in favor of niche segments where it can exert significant pricing power and maintain high customer retention rates, often exceeding 85%.

Competitive Landscape

AFG competes in the fragmented specialty insurance industry against both global multi-line insurers and boutique niche players. Its strategy prioritizes underwriting margins over top-line growth, a discipline that allows it to outperform during periods of market volatility. Key competitors that are publicly traded on major exchanges and feature active options markets include:

1. Chubb Limited: A global leader in P&C insurance that competes with AFG in various high-end commercial and specialty casualty lines.
2. Cincinnati Financial Corporation: A regional peer also based in Ohio, competing for independent agency relationships and commercial accounts across the Midwest and beyond.
3. Arch Capital Group Ltd.: A major competitor in the specialty insurance and reinsurance space, particularly in executive liability and professional lines.
4. W.R. Berkley Corporation: Shares a similar decentralized model and focuses on niche commercial markets, often competing for specialized underwriting talent.
5. American International Group: While a broader global insurer, AIG competes with AFG in several specialty commercial and financial lines.

Strategic Outlook and Innovation

For 2026, AFG’s strategic roadmap emphasizes "Smart Growth" and technological integration. The company is actively deploying AI-driven tools to enhance underwriting accuracy and streamline claims processing across its diverse business units. Following a record-breaking 2025, the firm entered 2026 with a target core operating ROE of approximately 18% and projected net written premium growth of 3% to 5%. A central pillar of its strategy remains a disciplined capital return policy; in February 2026, AFG once again declared a significant special dividend, continuing its trend of returning excess capital to shareholders when it cannot be profitably deployed in new acquisitions or organic growth.

Innovation at AFG is increasingly focused on addressing emerging risks, including cyber liability and climate-related agricultural shifts. By leveraging its in-house investment team, which manages a portfolio of approximately $17 billion as of late 2025, the company aims to capitalize on the "higher-for-longer" interest rate environment to bolster its net investment income. With a strong investment-grade balance sheet and a focus on high-quality fixed-income maturities, AFG is positioned to maintain its market-leading specialty status while navigating the evolving regulatory and legal landscapes of the insurance industry.

Want more examples? AES Covered Calls | AFK Covered Calls